Railway Recruitment Board Reasoning — Question 5258

Question

Read the given statement and the arguments carefully and select the appropriate answer from the given options. Statement: "If waste management capabilities of Hospital X are dealt with, we will definitely win the 'excellence in service' award for year 22-23." One of the board of directors from Hospital X. Arguments: I. In four separate incidents in the year 22-23, 15 patients lost their lives and 46 were injured due to various incidents such as fire breakout in ICU, lack of oxygen etc. II. Hospital A located in the nearby city has won 'excellence in service' award for a record five times.

  1. II weakens while I strengthens the statement.
  2. II weakens while I is a neutral argument
  3. I weakens while II is a neutral argument
  4. I weakens while II strengthens the statement.

Correct answer

C — I weakens while II is a neutral argument

Explanation (English)

Serious safety failures in I weaken the claim that waste management alone wins the award; Hospital A's wins in II say nothing about Hospital X, so II is neutral.

More Reasoning questions

Practice 1000+ more questions like this

TestPod AI has hand-curated previous-year-questions for SSC, RRB NTPC, IBPS PO, SBI Clerk, and more — with AI explanations in Tanglish, Hinglish, and English.

Download TestPod AI on Google Play